This is the story of the producer and two lip-syncing male models. The made millions of records and won a Grammy But it was a scam, they weren't real singers. The super cast includes: Paul Hickert as Jack, Sammy Curcuru as Young Jack, Winslow Fegley as Elmer's Son, Oakes Fegley as Jeffrey, Mary Jo Catlett as Elsie, William Bogert as Mr. Pauley, Brian Anthony Wilson as Ruben, Angela Pierce as Emily, Kimberley Shoniker as Young Elsie, Steve Blanchard as Edmund, Toni Sawyer as Mabel Pauley, Kelly McAndrew as Lynn, Kathy Patterson as Betty, Erik Parillo as TV News Reporter, Scott Watson as Thomas, Aaron Mathias as Stan, Jeff Panzarella as Angel Martinez and Jim Thalman as Young Elmer